I do love a wee bit of historical fiction, particularly tales set against Scotland’s rich, vibrant and often tempestuous past. As a child, I was hooked on novels about the Jacobite uprising, the Highland Clearances and Mary Queen of Scots. I loved to read fictional stories set against a backdrop of reality, a reality that was close to home. These books brought the past to life and gave me a chance to imagine real tales and real people. I have no doubt that it set me on the way to a life long love of learning about the past and the people who lived it. For me, this is the power of historical fiction.
Fast forward to today and I have had the pure joy of discovering Barbara Henderson’s novels over the last couple of years. Novels such as Fir For Luck, Punch and Black Water have brought time periods to life through stories of passion, adventure and courage. So, it probably comes as no surprise that I was delighted to be asked to be part of the blog tour of Barbara’s latest book, The Siege of Caerlaverock, which is set in the midst of the Scottish Wars of Independence.
Read on to hear about why Barbara thinks readers are so drawn to stories set during the Middle Ages, followed by my review of this staggeringly brilliant historical adventure.
The Medieval Appeal by Barbara Henderon
When I read that the Middle Ages were Kirsty Crommie’s favourite period of Scottish history, I had to smile. I have long been fascinated by the Middle Ages. I have written about the Victorians and 18th century smugglers in previous books, but The Siege of Caerlaverock goes back the furthest of all my published and unpublished work.
The idea had appealed for some time. Where better to set a tale than a mysterious castle? Surprisingly, when I gathered material for research, I did not find an abundance of comparable titles. Plenty fantasy worlds with semi-medieval settings, but full of dragons and beasts and magic. While I love those stories (I really do!), mine was going to be rooted in reality, I decided.
But it set me thinking – why do we love the Middle Ages? Why does that period appeal so much that it is constantly revived in new fantasy reincarnations?
Here are some of my guesses:
1. Weapons: Huge stones hurled through the air, catapults and trebuchets, halberds, swords and bows and arrows – the medieval period has it all, and many more besides. Let’s face it, who doesn’t love a good sword fight.
2. Dungeons: I think prisoners and captures often feature in stories, but there is something particularly evocative about a castle dungeon. The cold stone, the darkness, the torches and heavy iron grates. There is something romantically hopeless about that. I knew early on that I would need a prisoner in my castle story!
3. Horses: There is something so impressive and elegant about a horse galloping across a drawbridge, through the castle gates and into the courtyard. I have loved horses since I was young and even though I could never afford to own one, I love the sense of freedom and adventure they bring to stories.
4. Beauty: From Knights’ armour to the long-sleeved velvet dresses of the Lady of the Castle, there is something so sumptuous about that period. Even the horses were clad in the colourful heraldic symbols of the clan. Gorgeous tapestries adorned the castle walls and the floor of any great hall was strewn with rushes and sweet-smelling herbs and blossoms. There was candle-light everywhere! We all know that everyone looks good in candlelight 😊. It was first and foremost, a world of beauty.
5. Risk: This is the lifeblood of so many great stories – we need real, believable jeopardy in a story. The Middle Ages had this is spades, with their movable borders, feuding families, constant invasions and intrigues, even murders. Children were given real and meaningful tasks from an early age, and knights began their training aged around seven, making this period perfect for children’s books.
6. Religion, myth and folklore: The Middle Ages were steeped in the other world (perhaps this is another reason why so many medieval stories are hijacked for fantasy). Religion and the church play a pivotal part in the Siege of Caerlaverock, and thoughts of heaven and hell were never far away. Medieval Europe was also fertile ground for the ballads and stories of oral tradition. Bards and musicians were highly esteemed and all of this adds colour to the medieval world which is sometimes lacking in our secular mindset.
7. Kings and Wars: We may still retain a Royal family, but the sort of kings and queens who lived and died by their decisions, granted mercy or put to death with unquestioned authority are, thankfully, a thing of the past. Still, they unquestioningly make for good story material.
8. Buildings: Be they castles, burghs, humble huts or knights’ tents, the medieval dwellings evoke a sense of simplicity and strength.
9. Physical environment: The Middle ages are, first and foremost, a physical environment. Land had to be ploughed, honour had to be won in honest combat, butter had to be churned by hand, garments had to be stitched, horses groomed and armour polished. No machines and certainly no digital aspect – and in today’s overload of the latter, that is very appealing in a story.
10. Morality: In the Middle Ages, knights were bound by chivalry and the divisions between good and evil, holy and hellish, upright and base were stark. Crime was punished by revenge. People listened to the church with unquestioning trust and lived their lives dependent on charms, relics, confession and pilgrimage. Despite the fact that many of us would not want to live like this, there is an attractive clarity to that worldview. We can understand it and relate to it.
For my own medieval book, The Siege of Caerlaverock, I have tapped into many of these aspects without being conscious of it. It turns out that I was already hooked on the Middle Ages and I could not be happier that, now, if someone looks for medieval books for children, they may stumble across mine.
Review of The Siege of Caerlaverock by Barbara Henderson
I love children’s historical fiction. I believe that it is not only important in passing on an understanding of the past, but that it brings history to life for children. It is also an opportunity for authors to write some brilliant adventures set around real events.
When it comes to history and Scottish history, in particular, I get a bit geeky and, without a doubt, my favourite time period surrounds the Scottish Wars of Independence. It is exciting and gruesome. It is passionate and gritty. It is full of conflict and big decisions. For a children’s novel, it is just perfect.
You cannot imagine my delight when I heard that Barbara had written a book set in the year 1300, with the real life siege of Caerlaverock castle at its heart.
The story is centred around Caerlaverock Castle, a stunning moated triangular castle near Dumfries. (As an aside, I hear it is well worth a visit and is now on my list of places to see!) We are treated to a feast of information about the residents of the castle and their lives and daily routines are brilliantly and accurately described.
12 year old Ada is a laundress in the castle. Her days are pretty mundane and she would appear fairly insignificant. However, when she starts to help a young prisoner being held captive in the castle she changes her destiny for good. Together with her young friend, Godfrey, they build a story of friendship, trust, kindness and loyalty.
When the King of England, Edward Longshanks, marches towards the castle with his 3000 strong army, everyone’s life is suddenly in jeopardy. With the castle being defended by only 60 men, things look bleak. How can the castle inhabitants survive such an onslaught?
I’m not going to lie, this is probably one of my favourite books ever. Barbara Henderson tells the story with such detail and description that you get utterly drawn in and you will not want to put this book down. Although set in a time of war, where fear was prevalent, I loved the personal stories and interactions. There are beautiful elements that demonstrate humanity’s essential nature, where empathy, understanding and kindness persist.
I adored the central character of Ada. A strong young female who is courageous enough to follow her own path and do what she believes is right. At times she is scared, but she is determined and brave and has the strength to follow her heart.
The Seige of Caerlaverock is nothing short of a majestic and monumental piece of brilliance. It is full of emotion, determination and excitement against the backdrop of one of the most fascinating periods of Scottish history. I absolutely loved it and I hope children and adults alike will fall in love with it as much as I did.






